Why I Stopped Buying Burger Buns (And Made These Instead)
For a long time, burger night felt like a compromise.
I would cook good patties.
Add fresh toppings.
But the buns always felt… wrong.
Too soft.
Too processed.
And nutritionally empty.
I didn’t want to quit burgers.
I just wanted buns that actually made sense.
That’s when I stopped buying them—and started making these 4 Ingredient Protein Burger Buns instead.
Why store-bought burger buns never worked for me
Most burger buns are:
- mostly refined flour
- low in protein
- high in unnecessary sugar
They turn a decent meal into something heavy and forgettable.
I realized the bun wasn’t supporting the burger —
it was dragging it down.
What truly changed everything for me was switching to homemade 3 ingredient carnivore burger buns, which became the foundation of all my carnivore meals.
The decision that changed everything
One day, I made a simple decision:
If I’m making burgers at home,
the bun should add value, not just calories.
I didn’t want:
- complicated bread recipes
- yeast
- long proofing times
I wanted something fast, filling, and repeatable.
Why these homemade protein buns work
These buns work because each ingredient has a purpose:
- Eggs → structure + protein
- Greek yogurt → softness and moisture
- Oat or protein flour → substance and satiety
- Baking powder → light lift
They’re:
- sturdy enough to hold a burger
- soft inside
- easy to slice and toast
No crumbling.
No falling apart halfway through eating.
When I make these buns
I make them when:
- I want burgers without ultra-processed bread
- I’m meal-prepping for the week
- I want more protein without changing the meal
- I’m tired of “healthy swaps” that don’t work
Honest results
✔ More filling
✔ Better texture than expected
✔ Easy to customize
❌ Not fluffy like brioche
❌ Not sweet
But they’re functional, satisfying, and realistic — and that’s what matters.
Who this recipe is for
✅ Perfect if you:
- want high-protein meals
- cook burgers at home
- like simple ingredient lists
❌ Not ideal if you:
- want classic white buns
- avoid eggs or dairy
4 Ingredient Protein Burger Buns
- Prep Time: 10 minutes
- Cook Time: 20 minutes
- Total Time: 30 minutes
- Yield: 4 buns
- Category: Bread
- Method: Whisk, Bake
- Cuisine: American
- Diet: Low Fat
Description
Soft, high-protein burger buns made with just 4 ingredients. A simple alternative to store-bought bread.
Ingredients
-
2 large eggs
-
1 cup Greek yogurt
-
1 cup oat flour or protein flour
-
1 teaspoon baking powder
Instructions
-
Preheat oven to 180°C (350°F).
-
Whisk eggs and Greek yogurt until smooth.
-
Add flour and baking powder; mix into a soft dough.
-
Divide dough and shape into buns.
-
Bake for 18–20 minutes until set.
Notes
-
Let buns cool before slicing.
-
Toast lightly for best texture.
Nutrition
- Serving Size: 1 bun
- Calories: 150 kcal
- Sugar: 2 g
- Sodium: 180mg
- Fat: 4 g
- Carbohydrates: 18 g
- Fiber: 5g
Keywords: 4 ingredient protein burger buns
Are homemade protein buns better than store-bought?
They contain fewer processed ingredients and provide more protein per serving.
Can I freeze these burger buns?
Yes, let them cool completely, then freeze for later use.
Do these buns hold up well with juicy burgers?
Yes, they are sturdy enough for most homemade burgers
Can I use different protein powders?
Yes, but results will vary. The recipe is optimized for:
Nuzest pea protein: Neutral flavor, bakes well
Evo Hemp protein: Nutty flavor, healthy fats
Substitutions that work:
Other unflavored pea protein isolates
Blend of brown rice + pea protein
Collagen peptides (texture will be different)
Avoid:
Whey protein (gets rubbery when baked)
Flavored protein powders (unless going for sweet buns)
Soy protein (can be bitter)
Are these buns suitable for vegans?
No—they contain eggs. However, you can try:
Vegan egg replacements (experimental):
3 flax eggs (3 tbsp flaxmeal + 9 tbsp water, let sit 5 min)
Aquafaba (liquid from canned chickpeas—6 tbsp)
Note: Texture and protein content will change significantly.
Can I make these nut-free?
Yes! They already are! Despite the “nutty” flavor from hemp, these 4 ingredient protein burger buns contain:
❌ No tree nuts
❌ No peanuts
✅ Safe for nut allergies
Hemp is a seed, not a nut, and is generally safe for nut-allergic individuals. Always verify with your doctor.
How many net carbs are really in each bun?
3g net carbs per bun, calculated:
Total carbs: 8g
Minus fiber: 5g
Net carbs: 3g
This includes:
Carbs from eggs (minimal)
Carbs from protein powders (2-3g)
Carbs from baking powder (trace)
Can I use these for hot dog buns?
Absolutely! Just shape differently:
For hot dog buns:
Divide batter into 4 portions (instead of 3)
Shape into oval/oblong shapes (6 inches long, 2 inches wide)
Bake same temperature and time
Slice lengthwise instead of horizontally
Perfect for keto hot dog buns summer BBQs!
Will these work for sliders?
Yes! Make mini protein slider buns:
Divide batter into 6-8 small portions
Shape into 2-inch diameter rounds
Reduce baking time to 10-12 minutes
Perfect for parties and meal prep
Macros per slider bun (if making 6):
Protein: 13.5g
Net carbs: 1.5g
Calories: 139
How do I know if my baking powder is still good?
Test it: Add ¼ tsp baking powder to ¼ cup hot water.
Good: Immediate vigorous fizzing/bubbling
Bad: Minimal or no reaction
Expired baking powder = dense, flat buns. Replace every 6 months for best results.
Can I make these in advance for a BBQ?
Yes! Perfect for meal prep:
3 days ahead:
Make buns
Cool completely
Store in airtight container in fridge
Morning of BBQ:
Toast lightly to refresh
Bring to room temperature
Assemble burgers fresh
Or freeze weeks ahead and thaw day before.
Tag us and you might be featured on our page!
Pinterest: Pin for weekly meal planning
Welcome to the Looksyumy family, where simple ingredients create extraordinary results, and 27g of protein per bun is just the beginning.
Visit looksyumy.com for more revolutionary simple recipes that transform your kitchen and health.
Happy cooking! 🍔💪
